1. Introduction
What is AI and why is it important to regulate it?
In simple terms,Artificial intelligence (AI) is a broad field within computer science focused on developing machines that can carry out activities normally requiring human intelligence.
Regulation of AI is important because of the following reasons-
- To keep a check on bias in data sets used to train these models -The application of AI in hiring processes can, without any intention, make biases against vulnerable groups (racial and ethnic minorities, people with low incomes, homeless people, people in prison, people with physical or intellectual disabilities, people in the LGBTQ+ community etc.) worse.
Amazon, an early adopter of AI in hiring, attempted to lessen biases by excluding vulnerable group information. Despite efforts, biases persisted, leading Amazon to discontinue the AI-based hiring program in 2018.
- To prevent privacy invasion- AI systems often depend on personal data. Collecting and handling this data brings up issues about how it will be used and who can get to it. Main issues include the risk of data being stolen or accessed without permission.
advertisement
- To prevent misuse in surveillance or warfare - If these technologies aren’t properly controlled, they could lead to spying and reduce people’s privacy.
In wars, AI-powered weapons bring up issues about who’s responsible for their actions and whether they follow international laws. China is clearly leading in creating these technologies.
- To ensure Consumer Protection: AI-driven products and services impact consumers directly, from chatbots to financial advice algorithms. Regulations can ensure these technologies are safe, protecting consumers from harm.
- To promote sustainable use of AI- According to the MIT Technology Review, training a single AI model can result in emitting over 626,000 pounds of carbon dioxide equivalent, nearly five times the lifetime emissions of an average car. This shows the need for regulations in this domain.
2. Current Regulatory Framework
advertisement
What are the existing laws and policies on AI in India?
India does not have a complete and independent law specifically addressing artificial intelligence (AI). However, several existing laws and policies in India indirectly apply to various aspects of AI development and deployment :-
- The Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act) regulates electronic transactions and digital governance in India. While it does not directly address AI, certain provisions within it related to activities involving AI.
Section 43A allows for compensation when data privacy is breached because of careless handling of sensitive personal information, which is relevant to AI systems that process user data.
- In 2018, NITI Aayog unveiled the National Strategy on Artificial Intelligence (NSAI), outlining a roadmap to integrate AI into five key public sectors in a manner that ensures safety and benefits all citizens. The strategy introduced the "AI for All" mantra as a guiding principle for future AI design, development, and deployment in India.
The main focus of this plan is to make sure AI is used safely and responsibly. (RAI).
The RAI principles respond to the growing demand for rules and controls to reduce AI risks. Facial recognition technology (FRT) is the first example used to apply and improve these RAI principles and methods.
advertisement
In February 2021, NITI Aayog released Part 1 of its Principles for Responsible AI, detailing ethical considerations for using AI in India. It includes things like how decisions are made, ensuring the technology is used fairly, and who is responsible for it.
In August 2021, Part 2 was released, which focused on operationalizing these principles, outlining actions for government, private sector, and research institutes. These actions involve creating rules, improving skills, encouraging ethical AI design, and setting up systems to follow AI standards.
In 2018, NSAI introduced 'AIRAWAT '(Artificial Intelligence Research, Analytics, and Knowledge Assimilation Platform) for AI research and development through collaboration among academia, industry, and government agencies in India. Recently, 'AIRAWAT' achieved the 75th position in the global top 500 supercomputing list at the International Supercomputing Conference in Germany in 2023.
The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, was signed into law by the President of India on August 11, 2023. It regulates how digital personal data is handled throughout India, no matter its original format, and deals with privacy concerns related to AI platforms.
The Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) has established AI committees that have submitted reports addressing AI development, safety, and ethical concerns. MeitY launched the National Program on AI, known as India AI, to set the stage for AI innovation in India. This initiative aims to guide AI development and deployment, enhance skills among the Indian workforce for AI-related tasks, promote research and development in AI, and tackle ethical and regulatory issues. MeitY has also initiated several skill development programs aimed at training professionals in AI technologies and applications.
advertisement
- The National Program on Artificial Intelligence (India AI), launched by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY), is an important initiative aimed at guiding and accelerating the development of AI in India.
This program aims to create a supportive setting for AI development by focusing on a few key areas. It puts a strong emphasis on improving skills with special training and education, making sure that people in India are prepared to work well in AI research and use.
Sectoral initiatives-
In India, there are many efforts to use and control AI in different fields. Some are listed below-
- Telecom Sector: TRAI issued recommendations in July 2023 to promote responsible AI adoption in telecom. These include using AI and ML for network optimization, predictive maintenance, personalized services, spam prevention, and fraud detection.
- Agriculture Sector: AI's potential in precision farming, agricultural drones, and climate monitoring is recognized by the Indian government. Agri-Tech startups are developing AI solutions for supply chain management and market linkages.
- Healthcare Sector: Guidelines from the Indian Council of Medical Research address ethical concerns in AI use for medical research and healthcare delivery. Initiatives like the National AI Portal for Healthcare promote AI applications in medical imaging, predictive analytics, and telemedicine.
advertisement
- Education Sector: The NSAI (National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence) proposes AI-driven adaptive learning platforms and virtual assistants in education. The National Educational Technology Forum facilitates AI integration to enhance educational quality and accessibility.
- Finance Sector: AI and ML applications in finance cover areas such as customer due diligence, credit assessment, fraud detection, and regulatory oversight. The RBI(Reserve Bank of India) is developing AI systems to improve regulatory supervision of banks and NBFCs.( Non-Banking Financial Company)
These efforts show how India is using AI in many ways while also tackling issues about rules, ethics, and practical use in different areas.
advertisement
3. Ethical and Legal Considerations
How do we address bias and ensure fairness in AI?
We can address bias in AI algorithms by-
Building Diverse Development Teams: Creating AI development teams with diverse backgrounds and perspectives promotes the creation of unbiased systems.
Collecting Diverse Data:It's important to collect training data that includes a variety of people and groups to ensure different viewpoints and experiences are represented.
Incorporating Human Oversight: Adding human decision-making to AI helps reduce biases and makes sure the results are fair and ethical. Human oversight provides a critical check to correct errors and biases that automated systems may miss.
Ensuring Algorithmic Transparency: Making AI algorithms transparent and understandable is essential for identifying biases. Clear algorithms let people check how decisions are made, which helps build trust and accountability.
4. Challenges and Opportunities
What are the challenges in implementing AI regulations?
advertisement
Challenges in implementing AI regulations include-
Inability to define AI: AI is used in many applications, from self-driving cars to recommendation systems. One general definition might not cover all the details for each specific situation.
Unforeseen Risks: AI systems can create new risks that are hard to predict. For example, the dangers of deep fakes weren’t fully realized until the technology became widely available.
Cultural Differences: Different countries have varying cultural, ethical, and legal frameworks, making it challenging to develop universally accepted AI regulations. Companies might go to places with weaker rules, which can make the competition unfair.
Deciding the extent of regulation: Too many rules can slow down innovation by making it expensive and hard to try new things. On the other hand, not having enough rules can allow dangerous AI systems to be used without proper safety measures.
Shortage of Technical Expertise: Many regulatory agencies don't have the technical know-how to properly monitor AI development and use. Coordinating rules and enforcement across various countries is also complicated and takes a lot of time.
What potential benefits can AI regulation bring?
Potential benefits of AI include-
Safety and Reliability: Ensures that AI systems are safe and reliable, particularly in critical areas like healthcare, transportation, and finance. This would prevent AI systems from perpetuating or amplifying biases, ensuring equitable treatment for all.
Level Playing Field: AI regulation would create a fair competitive environment by preventing anti-competitive practices related to AI.
Ethical Guidelines: Creating rules for ethical AI development and use would help build public trust by showing that risks are being handled properly.
advertisement
Conclusion
In the future, India is increasingly realizing the need for detailed rules to manage how AI is developed, used, and its ethical issues. Key initiatives such as the Digital Personal Data Protection Act,2023 and efforts by regulatory bodies like NITI Aayog and the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) show how India is dedicated to promoting responsible AI development while protecting the interests of society.
Regulations should be made to create an environment that promotes responsible AI development and use, making sure that AI innovations benefit the economy and society.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)-
1. Is my data protected when AI is involved?
In India, whether a user's data is protected when AI is involved depends largely on the website's terms and conditions. It's essential for users to carefully read and understand these terms before sharing personal information.
2. How can I protect myself from potential AI misuse?
Staying informed about AI developments, being careful with personal information online, and being alert to scams are important steps. Supporting responsible AI development and use is also essential.
advertisement
3. How can AI contribute to addressing India's issues such as poverty, healthcare, and education?
AI has the capacity to transform sectors like agriculture, healthcare, and education. For example, AI can forecast crop yields, interpret medical images, and customize educational content.
4. How can I prepare myself for a future with AI?
Improving digital skills and learning more about AI are crucial for adapting to the changing job market. Digital literacy means knowing how to use digital tools and technologies, which are becoming more important in many industries.
5. What are the penalties for non-compliance with AI regulations in India?
India lacks a dedicated AI law. Current penalties rely on existing laws like IT Act, Consumer Protection Act, Digital Personal Data Protection Act and Indian Penal Code.
advertisement
References
What is Artificial Intelligence (AI)?
AI hiring bias: Everything you need to know
AI and Privacy: The privacy concerns surrounding AI, its potential impact on personal data
Geopolitical implications of AI and digital surveillance adoption
Protecting Information with Cybersecurity
The Information Technology Act, 2000
National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence
Responsible AI: Part 1 - Principles for Responsible AI
The Key Policy Frameworks Governing AI in India
AI Regulation in India: Current State and Future Perspectives
AIRAWAT- Establishing an AI Specific Cloud Computing Infrastructure in India
Salient Features of the Digital Personal Data Protection Bill, 2023
India; AI regulation- current state and future
AI, Machine Learning and Big Data laws and regulations 2024
AI Watch: Global regulatory tracker- India
Recommendations on Leveraging Artificial Intelligence and Big Data in Telecommunication Sector
Ethical Guidelines for the Application of Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare
The Personal Data Protection Bill,2019
advertisement
India: AI regulation - current state and future perspectives
AI Ethics and Bias: Ensuring Fairness in Machine Learning Algorithms
The Three Challenges of AI Regulation
Written by Priyanshi Gupta
Priyanshi is a first-year Law student at National Law University, Jabalpur, currently pursuing BALLB. My interests lie in exploring emerging areas of law. She is eager to delve into the impact of ever evolving technologies on the legal landscape.
advertisement
Further Reading
advertisement
