Not all statements can be considered defamation. There are few primary grounds that need to be fulfilled first for a statement to be considered defamation:
1. Publication or Communication
For a statement to be considered defamatory, it must be published or communicated to a third party. Third party can be any person, and does not need to be a group of people. It can also be a single person. This can be in written form (libel), spoken form (slander), or via other media like TV, radio, or the internet.
2. False Statement
The statement in question must be false. Truth is a valid defense against defamation. If the statement is true, it cannot be considered defamatory, even if it harms the person's reputation.
3. Harm to Reputation
The statement must harm the reputation of the person or entity. This means it should lower the person's standing in the eyes of society or make others avoid them.
4. Identifiable Person
The defamatory statement must refer to an identifiable person. This means that the statement should be clear enough that people understand who it is about, even if the person's name is not explicitly mentioned.
5. Intention or Negligence
The person making the defamatory statement must have done so intentionally or negligently. In other words, they must have intended to harm the person's reputation or been careless enough to not realize the statement could be harmful.
advertisement
Legal Provisions
Civil Defamation
Under civil law, a defamation suit can be filed for damages or compensation. The aggrieved party must prove the above grounds in a civil court.
Criminal Defamation
Under Sections 499 and 500 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), defamation is also a criminal offense. The difference between civil and criminal defamation is the degree of punishment. Section 499 defines what constitutes defamation, and Section 500 prescribes the punishment, which can be up to two years in prison, a fine, or both.
Exceptions
There are certain exceptions where a statement, though potentially harmful to someone's reputation, is not considered defamatory under Section 499 IPC. These include:
Truth for Public Good: If the statement is true and made for the public good.
Fair Criticism: Fair criticism of public servants in the discharge of their public functions.
Public Conduct: Public opinion on the conduct of persons who have a public character or are engaged in public affairs.
Judicial Proceedings: Statements made in the course of judicial proceedings.
Literary Criticism: Fair criticism of literary or artistic works.
Filing a Defamation Suit
To file a defamation suit, follow these steps:
Consult a Lawyer: Contact a lawyer to evaluate the strength of your case and guide you through the legal process.
Notice to Defendant: In civil defamation, it is customary to send a legal notice to the defendant, giving them a chance to apologize or retract the defamatory statement.
advertisement
File a Complaint
- a. Civil Defamation: File a complaint in the appropriate civil court seeking damages or an injunction.
- b. Criminal Defamation: File a criminal complaint under Sections 499 and 500 of the IPC in the magistrate's court.
Present Evidence: Give evidence to prove that you have been defamed. This can include a voice recording, a text message, witness to public humiliation, video recording etc. Also show the harm caused, and the intention or negligence of the defendant.
Court Proceedings: Attend court hearings, provide witness testimonies, and submit all relevant documents and evidence.
advertisement
FAQs
FAQ 1: What constitutes defamation under Indian law?
Answer: Defamation in India occurs when a false statement is made, published, or spoken, causing harm to someone's reputation. It can be civil or criminal under Sections 499 and 500 of the IPC. More information about IPC can be found here.
FAQ 2: What are the steps to file a defamation suit?
Answer: To file a defamation suit, gather evidence of the defamatory statement, file a complaint with the police, and consult a lawyer to file a case in the appropriate court.
Written by Arshita Anand
Arshita is a final year student at Chanakya National Law University, currently pursuing B.B.A. LL.B (Corporate Law Hons.). She is enthusiastic about Corporate Law, Taxation and Data Privacy, and has an entrepreneurial mindset
advertisement
Further Reading
advertisement
