Vaquill is a legal publication house that simplifies legal information and publishes content in multiple Indian languages.

What languages does Vaquill publish in?

Vaquill publishes content in English, Hindi, Marathi, Tamil, Telugu, and Bangla.

West Bengal's Aparajita AntiRape Bill - A Game Changer or a Political Ploy?

Image this: a world where justice seems out of reach, and the pain of victims often goes unheard.

Sounds like dystopian fiction, right? Sadly, this is the harsh reality and crisis our country is in the middle of. The Aparajita Anti-Rape Bill, passed by the West Bengal Assembly, promises to crack down on sexual crimes with tough measures, including the death penalty for rapists and strict deadlines for investigations.

Named after the young doctor who was brutally raped and murdered on August 9, 2024 during her duty hours within the premises of the hospital: RG Kar Medical College and Hospital, Kolkata, the bill stands as a symbol of the state’s pledge to protect women. But here is where it gets complicated—while some see it as a bold step towards justice, others believe it is more about making headlines than making a difference.

With similar bills from Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh waiting for approval, the future of the Aparajita Bill is uncertain. Will it change the landscape of women's safety, or will it get lost in the noise?

This is a conversation we can't afford to ignore.

Key Provisions of the Aparajita Anti-Rape Bill

Death Penalty for Rape Convictions: The bill introduces the death penalty for certain rape cases, particularly those involving minors or extreme brutality. This is one of its most debated aspects, with some administrative officials claiming it will intimidate rapists. However, some legal experts argue that the death penalty could backfire, discouraging victims from reporting the crime if the perpetrator is a close relative or known to them.
21-Day Investigation Mandate: One of the bill’s most ambitious goals is to complete investigations of rape cases within 21 days. The state hopes this will lead to quicker justice, sparing victims the trauma of long legal proceedings. However, the practicality of this timeline has been questioned, especially given the state's already overburdened police force and slow-moving judiciary. Critics fear that such a short timeline might lead to rushed or incomplete investigations, potentially impacting the quality of justice.
Penalties for Unauthorised Media Coverage: The bill also includes provisions to penalize media outlets that publish unauthorized details of rape cases. This is intended to protect victims from public shame and prevent sensational reporting. However, media organisations and free speech advocates worry that such provisions might restrict press freedom, limiting public access to crucial information and reducing transparency in high-profile cases.

Ongoing Challenges

Awaiting Presidential Approval: While West Bengal has passed the Aparajita Bill, it is still awaiting approval from the President of India. This step is important , as laws concerning criminal penalties require the President's consent to become legitimate. Other states, such as Maharashtra with its Shakti Bill and Andhra Pradesh with its Disha Bill, have also passed similar laws but are stuck at the same stage. This raises concerns about how long it might take before the Aparajita Bill can be enforced.
Potential Legal obstacles: Legal experts believe the bill could face challenges in court. The death penalty provision and the strict investigation timelines might be contested for violating constitutional rights or being impractical. Additionally, the penalties for media outlets could clash with the right to free speech and press, leading to further legal complications.

Criticism from Victim Advocates and Legal Experts

Effectiveness Questioned: In the high-profile Kolkata rape and murder case that inspired the bill, the victim’s lawyer has been vocal in criticizing the law. He called the Aparajita Bill "absolutely useless," arguing that it doesn’t address the root causes of sexual violence or strengthen the investigation and judicial processes enough. He believes the bill focuses too much on punishment after the fact, rather than creating a safer environment for women to prevent such crimes in the first place.

As quoted in Amnesty International: “The authorities must deliver justice and accountability for the horrific rape and murder of the woman doctor at the RG Kar Medical College and hospital in Kolkata in August.

However, the death penalty is never the solution, nor would it offer a ‘quick fix’ to prevent violence against women. There is no evidence that it has a unique deterrent effect. Even the Justice Verma Committee that was constituted in 2012 to reform the laws and criminal justice practices relating to crimes of sexual violence, including rape in India and Law Commission of India have opposed the death penalty in cases of violence against women.

“What is actually needed is far-reaching procedural and institutional reform that deals with the root causes of crime and puts emphasis on its prevention.

Authorities in West Bengal and across India must fully implement recommendations made by the Justice Verma Committee, including police training and reform, preventive measures, and addressing how reports of sexual violence are registered and investigated. These are important first steps that will in the long run make India safer, including for women.

We urge the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) to conduct a swift and thorough investigation into this appalling case and bring those responsible to justice without recourse to the death penalty. Undue delays will further the climate of fear, impunity and uncertainty.”

Illustrative image showing indian judical systemr

Challenges in Implementation: Critics argue that the bill’s real impact on women’s safety will be minimal if it is not accompanied by policy-oriented measures. Fast-tracking investigations in 21 days sounds effective on paper, but without adequate resources, well-trained officers, and efficient judicial mechanisms, justice may still be delayed. Moreover, harsher penalties like the death sentence could lead to fewer convictions, as courts might hesitate to impose such extreme measures without conclusive proof.

On the other hand, the Supreme Court hearing for the RG Kar rape-murder case after the previous two hearing, originally set for today: September 5th, 2024, has been postponed due to the unavailability of the Chief Justice of India.

Though the court hearing was postponed, Kolkata’s resolve remained strong. As the clock struck 9 on Wednesday evening: September 4, 2024, the lights went out across the city. With candles in hand, the citizens once again stood together on the streets: a symbol of hope in the darkness, fighting for justice for the victim of the RG Kar rape-murder case.

Conclusion

The Aparajita Anti-Rape Bill marks a significant step by West Bengal to address sexual violence, with tough penalties and strict timelines. However, it is not without its flaws. Critics argue that without addressing deeper systemic issues, such as better law enforcement, quicker court proceedings, and preventive measures, the bill may end up being more symbolic than impactful. As the bill awaits the President's approval, its ultimate success will depend on how well it can be implemented and whether it leads to real changes in the way sexual violence is tackled in the state.

Whether the Aparajita Bill becomes a game-changer or just another piece of legislation will be determined by its practical effects on the ground and the continued efforts to create a safer environment for women.

References:

Written by Seersha Chaudhuri

Driven legal professional with a BA LLB and a knack for writing and media reporting. Previously, I’ve crafted legal documents and managed court proceedings at Terkiana PC, focusing on immigration law. I’m also brushing up on my Spanish with Duolingo—learning a new language has never been this fun! Eager to blend my expertise in legal research with my passion for global policy and creative writing. Apart from being a professional, I am a full time lover of fish, dystopian fiction and Brooklyn 99.